Everything wrong with the Fellowship Of The Ring (movie version)

[Thomas Koenig]

In the discussion of the merits (or rather lack thereof) of the film
adaptions of LotR, here is an amusing piece.

I am glad to say that almost all mistakes pointed out in this video
are from the movie adaption, not the book.

Here it is:

[Paul S. Person]

On Sun, 13 Dec 2015 16:17:42 +0000 (UTC), Thomas Koenig

Post by Thomas Koenig
In the discussion of the merits (or rather lack thereof) of the film
adaptions of LotR, here is an amusing piece.
I am glad to say that almost all mistakes pointed out in this video
are from the movie adaption, not the book.
http://youtu.be/xLoobrbKepE

Every one of these that I have watched has been hilarious. Regardless
of how I felt about the film.

[Taemon]

Post by Thomas Koenig
In the discussion of the merits (or rather lack thereof) of the film
adaptions of LotR, here is an amusing piece.
I am glad to say that almost all mistakes pointed out in this video
are from the movie adaption, not the book.
http://youtu.be/xLoobrbKepE

The nazgûl sniffing out the hobbits hiding under that tree is such a
stupid scene. PJ should never have included it. It's one of the most
painful discrepancies between the book-starting-out-as-children's-book
and the book-turning-dark-and-for-adults.

Now I'm going to watch all the videos in this series :-)

[Taemon]

Post by Thomas Koenig
In the discussion of the merits (or rather lack thereof) of the film
adaptions of LotR, here is an amusing piece.
I am glad to say that almost all mistakes pointed out in this video
are from the movie adaption, not the book.
http://youtu.be/xLoobrbKepE

That scene with the nazgûl sniffing out the hobbits hiding under the
tree is so stupid. PJ should never have included it. It's one of the
most painful discrepancies between the book-as-children's-book and the
book-turned-dark-and-adulty.

Now I'm going to watch the other videos in this series :-)

[Taemon]

It didn't want to send! So I wrote it anew. Then it secretly had sent it
after all so now you can all see how well my memory works. Embarrassing.
Do ignore.

[Paul S. Person]

Post by Taemon

Post by Thomas Koenig
In the discussion of the merits (or rather lack thereof) of the film
adaptions of LotR, here is an amusing piece.
I am glad to say that almost all mistakes pointed out in this video
are from the movie adaption, not the book.
http://youtu.be/xLoobrbKepE

That scene with the nazgûl sniffing out the hobbits hiding under the
tree is so stupid. PJ should never have included it. It's one of the
most painful discrepancies between the book-as-children's-book and the
book-turned-dark-and-adulty.
Now I'm going to watch the other videos in this series :-)

The /Hunger Games/ ones (well, the first two, the ones I have seen)
aren't bad either.

As I said, I enjoy them whether I like the film or not.